Paul Ryan’s speech to the Republican National Convention will be praised by unthinking pundits today for its success is revving up the GOP base — and you can only shake your head at what that takes these days. From early reactions, I suspect the speech will be a litmus test for how much of the media made it to adulthood. Those who failed will likely ignore the destructive, infantile message Ryan was sending to the American people, proving how little he understands about a modern economy and how nations become strong and its people prosperous.
At a key moment, his voice rising, Ryan told the nation they should fear the “central planners” who are apparently sapping the entrepreneurial life juices from the American soul. That got a standing ovation from today’s Republican Party. Meanwhile, a thousand miles away, the Army Corp of Engineers, the epitome of government central planning, was operating the pumps and flood gates along the levees in and around the City of New Orleans desperately trying to keep the city from drowning again.
New Orleans did drown, seven years ago, as the nation and a clueless President watched helplessly from above. Mr. Bush was someone who believed, just as Paul Ryan does, that collective action in the public interest and government-funded public investments done with careful central planning are not an essential part of his job, unless you’re building aircraft carriers to facilitate wars you just lied the country into. As he circled the disaster of a drowning city, the pathetic President may have foreseen his approval ratings tanking as the unchecked flood waters rose, stranding thousands of victims. But that’s not the nightmare little Paul Ryan has.
No, 12 year old Paul Ryan worries that if the government at any level acts in the community interest to further the public good, then “some” *cough* kinds of people will view government programs as a “hammock” in which they will lie back and cease to strive. They will just live off the dole, at the expense of the “real” Americans, who themselves will get lazy and stop building all those small businesses that somehow sprang up in towns whose histories we’ve forgotten, whose streets, and lamplights, and water and sewer systems somehow spontaneously appeared. And we won’t mention the highways that carry goods and customers to and from that I-built-this self-made business, nor mention the small business loans, or the courts that enforce the contracts, or the levees that protect the city, nor the National Guard that helps out in times of crisis.
Today, my 93 year old dad — bless him — will be a passenger in a two truck caravan leaving Sacramento, California, packed with his last belongings, and driven by my little sister and brother in law. They’re headed towards Las Cruces, New Mexico, my home town and where my Dad worked for 45 years before retiring. They’ll be traveling partly on relatively safe highways, part of the Interstate Highway system built by that commie collectivist, Dwight D. Eisenhower.
Las Cruces began as a thriving farming community that survived on the controlled waters of the Rio Grande River. Its flows are centrally managed from two modest up-river dams and reservoirs built by government in the Great Depression by a country knocked flat on its back by another private market financial collapse, but with the gumption to get up, willing to invest in the nation’s future and realizing it had an obligation to put able men to work to feed their families and build the things that needed building.
The town thrived again when it became the location of what is now New Mexico State University, one of those land grant ag colleges authorized by the American government starting a century and a half ago because the American people believe there was a community interest in educating its citizens at low cost to students and struggling families. It’s now a center of knowledge, engineering and agricultural research for all of Southern New Mexico.
Later on, Las Cruces would grow further from defense contractors and military researchers who worked out at the University’s Physical Science Lab or at White Sands Missile Range, just across the pass in the Organ Mountains to the east. That industry has since grown and there’s a NASA facility just up the mesa near the pass.
Today, Las Cruces is also becoming a retirement community, like much of the Southwest, and it’s a nice place to retire. Seniors can do that now, because no matter what else happened, they know — or knew until Paul Ryan’s band of juvenile delinquents came along — that they can count on Medicare covering most of their medical costs and Social Security providing a modest retirement income, even though the private investment markets looted and wiped out their life savings and the unregulated private banksters blew up the home equity they thought they’d have for retirement.
Thank heaven for Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security, because they too will help make Las Cruces a good place to retire. But don’t thank 12 year old Paul Ryan, because he just flat lied last night about how Medicare is still going to be there, not just for his mom, but for his kids. He’s going to replace it with a voucher system whose funding will grow more slowly that the cost of care, and Medicare beneficiaries will have to make up the difference or go without care. As for those seniors who rely on Medicaid — their security is now at risk because of Ryan’s budget plans.
Social Security may/may not fare better, but if it survives the 12 year olds and the faux adults in the White House and the scoundrels on the infamous catfood commission, it will only be because in 1983, a group of central planners decided they should raise the retirement age and increase taxes to create a multi-decade Trust Fund — now up to $2.7 trillion — that would cover retirees in the post-War baby boom while the federal government let taxes on the wealthy fall. Now it’s time for the wealthy to pay their share of that bargain, but 12 year old Paul Ryan wants to give them even more tax cuts in the name of “fiscal responsibility.” Give little Paul Ryan an “F” in responsible fiscal policy and civics.
Paul Ryan’s entire premise is so juvenile, so ridiculous, so oblivious to the reality of everyone’s everyday life that his speech should go down as one of the most absurd ever delivered at a national convention. But will any of our elite pundits notice?
As I said, this is a litmus test. Let’s see how many of our elite media make themselves look ridiculous by praising little Paul Ryan’s juvenile speech vs how many actually made it to adulthood. God helps us all, god save the central planners, and keep my family safe today.
John Chandley




22 Comments
12 year old ??? Most republicans today have the emotional maturity of a selfish, self centered badly parented 2 year old.
Yes, in their minds, it would be wrong of them to forget about those…
Two year olds don’t pretend to get wonky, but I’m open to debate on what level of maturity this is. Also, iirc, you don’t really parent a two year old. You just sorta survive until they grow out of it.
Best piece you have ever written.
If I were king, I’d have a ocpy printed and delivred to each and every home in the nation.
Ryan and the republican party of today are the most dastardly, despicable, greedy, selfish, lying bastards ever to walk our great land. And for those who disagree, just listen to them. They prove it every single day.
Heh, ain’t that right? But, what are we going to do while we’re waiting for the Terrible Two’s to pass? Oh, I know. Stay involved. Read what we can. Support projects we believe in.
Thanks, Scarecrow, and I’ll say a little prayer for your family’s safe travels.
PS, the female adolescent reaction is, Goll, he’s got just the dreamiest blue eyes.
It’s difficult to imagine the country without “central planners.” Maybe Ryan should attempt to plan a highway system, for example. The Rs have been childish since Reagan because he was so simple-minded.
Scarecrow, I hope your father has a wonderful retirement in New Mexico. It would be hard to find a more beautiful place.
yes, toddlers in perpetual temper tantrums certainly at the convention in Tampa and in the “Democratic” party too.
It’s a vital time in a toddler’s developmental life to parent well, so they don’t have to repeat it over and over in their subsequent years.
I recently had a conversation with a man who deems himself progressive, but thought that the catfood commission had all the right answers. He actually didn’t know what I was talking about until I explained the catfood commission was known as simpson-bowles. He thought that SS, Medicare, and Medicaid was going to bankrupt the country unless retirement age was raised and the Meds were cut. I explained to him that SS was not part of the debt and the retirement age had already been raised, so they are talking about raising it again. I also explained that simply raising the FICA taxable limit or ending the limit entirely would make the problems disappear. He grudgingly accepted that. I also said that if we stopped the wars, the fiscal problems would disappear. That was also grudginly accepted. There were other points of disagreement because if he doesn’t see it on msm news, 60 minutes, or read it in the nyt, it didn’t happen or it isn’t worth knowing. This is the state of our progressive movement, so ryan has a lot of company on the D side of the aisle.
As ever, Scarecrow, your writing is excellent. Thanks for the post.
Regarding that photo, I was surprised to see AA as the photographer, proving that even an excellent photographer can take and sell an ugly photo.
But then Picasso got $500 years ago for just his signature.
Well, it’s not clear what adam’s intent was. He wasn’t exactly a fan of massive developments in wild areas. Don’t think he would have approved of the Hetch Hetchy dam systems built in the Sierras, that provides part of the electricity for San Francisco. There is a whole other way of looking at central planning vs nature, but that is another topic. some of the early plans for transforming the sf bay are frightening.
Agreed on all counts. Las Cruces is one of my favorite little towns anywhere.
Thanks. Yes, the view of the Organ mountains is beautiful. He’ll see that in his new home.
Well, there was some fact checking, and yep, a GOLD for lying.
Having been through the sort of transition your family is involved in now, I wish your father and your family all the best. It is tough on these older folks to make this change.
It is enough that we are all doing this and more to keep our families going, but it is too much to deal with the realities that the likes of Ryan propose. I am so totally unenthusiastic to support the President, and moreso because he gets away with throwing us all under the bus, but if there is any chance that Rmoney and company are going to be elected (and yes, the electronic manipulation too), I will vote for O.
Didn’t those same “central planners” help make the family road construction business a success?
oh, more facts. Anyone at the paper of record or the TeeVeeNews?
Eh? They noticed alright, but hacks, like Blitzer, are highly paid
whoresshills for the 1%. They’re handsomely remunerated to ignore reality whilst they get down on their knees andfellatepraise RMoney/RZombie for all theliespropoganda they arecoughing out like hair ballspeddling.My sister and brother-in-lax retired from Minnesota to Las Cruces two years ago.
Thanks for this post.
He was a supporter of nukes, which is one of the reasons he parted ways with The Sierra Club.
Anyway, I only was referring to my pov of what makes a great photograph, which I learned (partially) from him!
About those highways. If you really want the right wing to like the idea, build them and sell them to the rich for fifty cents on the dollar and let them make turn them into toll roads. Profits you know. That’s what they build.
Sounds really nice.
Hi, Jim.
Wishing your dad a safe and sound trip, and a wonderful new life in his new home, Scarecrow. Thanks for this post, it reminds us that the lies of the GOP really matter, every day, to real Americans leading our real lives.
I seem to remember AA being hired by the WPA to document a bunch of the infrastructure projects. So this was a “job” he was paid to do and not one of his own ideas.
Of course once he became a ‘famous artist’ even those “job photos” were added to the collection of all of his work.