This election year was looking bleak for Democrats in the Senate simply because of how lopsided the playing field is. Democrats have 23 seats to defend, while the Republicans who only need to defend 10 seats.
But Senate Democrats’ hopes to keep control of the chamber received a huge boost when Maine’s Republican Senator Olympia Snowe made the surprise announcement she would not seek another term. A win in Maine will be critical for Democrats to make up almost assured losses elsewhere.
Snowe is an historic anomaly in our modern political system. She is a well liked Republican representing what by many measures is a Democratic state. She likely would have won re-election in spite of her party label, because during her decades long history as a public figure she has built a lot of personal good will with voters. People were voting for her and not her party. She is basically a Senate remnant from a different political time. With her personal appeal out of the picture, the Senate seat should revert back to modern political patterns.
Maine has become a state that now strongly favors Democrats. That is why during a huge 2010 Republican wave, Democrats still managed to hold on to both of Maine’s congressional districts.
It is the 12th most Democratic state and 12th most liberal state according to Gallup. It is also the state where President Obama has his 16th highest job approval rating.
In 2008 Obama only won 52.9% of the national popular vote, but he carried Maine with 57.7% of the vote. This made Maine Obama ‘s 11th best performing state. With 2012 being a presidential year, turnout among young voters that lean Democratic should again be high.
Unless there’s a Republican candidate who is incredibly popular, which currently doesn’t appear to exist, or a massive national swing towards the Republican party before November, a Democrat should win this seat.
One aspect of the growing polarization and unification of political parties in America is that elections become more predictable based on demographic trends. Legacy politicians like Snowe who managed over decades to make themselves their own brand could buck this national dynamic. With Snowe and her brand gone, though, what will likely matter most is the party brands. And in Maine the preferred brand is clearly Democratic.



33 Comments
It’s a blue state, and deserves at least one Democratic Senator.
In 2014, maybe Collins will follow suit!
You don’t have to convince me. I’m already celebrating.
Jon, and, if I haven’t thanked you recently for all that you do and how you do it…….remind me later. :-)
Angus King, former independent governor, considered extremely popular, was mentioned as a possible candidate on NPR this morning.
I know little about him, but he did praise both Snowe and Collins when saying they didn’t need to be replaced by himself or anyone.
I’m not sure what you mean by that quote, unless you are suggesting that both major parties are unifying and moving toward the upper (authoritarian) right (global, corporate controlled economic system) corner of the Political Compass.
Ah, so the seat goes from a “moderate” Republican to an independent politician or a corporate Democrat. Huzzah! I guess….
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/29/david-dreier-retirement-california-congressman_n_1310215.html?ref=politics
A GOP Senator retires thats one thing a chairman of the very powerful rules committee also retires then we have to start asking what the GOP’s private polling is showing.
David and Olympia both have would problems getting Tea Bagger votes my guess is more GOP moderates will retire.
What diff does it make which party wins the seat. Yawn.
What’s the story on the governor or ME? Isn’t he right there with walker, daniels, scott, etc? How far from the repug party line did snowe or collins stray? As I recall, 0 was playing his ‘bipartisany’ game of trying to get one repug, snowe or collins, to join him in the execrable game of health care law, but it didn’t work. The two senators didn’t say that they would support a better law, they simply would not join him. I’ll not hold my breath expecting a dim victory in ME. It could very well be a repeat of Coakley in MA, where “it was all her fault” as I have seen dims write.
Entirely correct, except one less excuse for super majority, do nothing Reid.
If we see more GOPers retire then the GOP itself knows they are in trouble this election. But so far 2 retirements does not prove trend only a possibility of a trend.
You better believe the Obama people will be recruiting a DLC blue dog and trashing any promising liberal Democrat. I tend to join eCahnomics in a big yawn.
+1, Ralph.
Also broader but admittedly more abstract good news for D political fortunes is the further evidence that the R party is no place for a reasonable woman.
This was a very late announcement. I ascribe it to Birth Control February.
Democrats need as many “hopeful” signs as they can get. With Obama back at 43% in Gallup–where he was last August–it seems the strategies he’s been trying just have not worked. Tax the rich, OWS, Do Nothing Congress, etc. all of them have fallen flat.
Maybe, he should try, “Govern.” or “politics, the art of persuading.” Though, I think his meeting today with all 4 congressional leaders may be a sign he is going to try “go along, get along” again.
The way things are going, it is not a sure thing that even Maine will vote a Dem into the Senate.
Now I know more or less about Maine more or less. Before, all I knew was it’s where GHWB holds court, and where Sandy Koufax lived with his bride, Richard Widmark’s daughter, and entertained George and Laura before being divorced. I’ve had Maine lobster, but that was in New Hampshire and Sheepshead Bay at Lundy’s. I’ve read that most of Maine is wilderness and privately owned for hunting. In Civics I learned that Maine has as much republican power as New York and California in this democracy.
Not sure what we gain by buying into this corporate-speak “brand” meme, but okay. The question is whether we get a corporate DEMOCRAT or someone willing to break out of the bi-party mode to which we are all held hostage. If we’re going to call ourselves progressives we cannot just go running right back to the Democratic herd like frightened sheep every time elections near, anyway.
This article would have been more useful if it probed beneath that bourgeois-democratic surface to let us know what progressive forces are like in Maine, and whether they can help bring someone useful into power, a la Vermont.
That article needs writing, you are correct!
I look forward to your writeup at MyFDL, Firedoglake’s diary site. You seem motivated and interested in bringing us the news. What are the progressive forces like in Maine? Can they bring someone useful into power, as Vermont has?
Thanking you in advance.
I think a democrat in that seat will be helpful.
Why????????????? I’m not really sure. Can I get back to you on that?
LePage is a Kochroach tool who “won” with about 30% of the vote when the majority was split between two others. As a Mainer, I can safely say that Maine has its share of teabagger morons — 30% of the population, apparently, or at least 30% of those who voted in 2010 or whenever it was — especially out in the hinterlands away from Portland and southern and coastal Maine, where the people are much more educated and conscious.
As far as a “democrat” getting Olympia Snowe’s seat — whatever. The “democrats” are dead to me now, so I really don’t give a shit or have any illusion that a “democrat” will do anything principled or conscious or great. I got an e-mail this morning from “Bold Progressives” hyping Chellie Pingree, currently a Maine Congresswoman, as a candidate for Snowe’s seat. I checked the vote on the latest abomination out of the House of Representatives, the “No Trespass” bill, and sure enough, ironically, “progressive” Pingree voted AYE just yesterday, so in my reply I ripped her a new one and said I no longer voted for “democrats,” especially fake “progressive” ones who vote to squash our First Amendment rights, apparently in anticipation of renewed OWS occupations and the NATO/G8 Summit this summer.
The idea that “democrats” are going to be “better” is a crock o shit. They haven’t been “better” at all, and there’s no reason to think they’re going to be “better” anytime soon.
Soon as I finish this five-year-long dissertation project on the food sovereignty movement in the Caribbean, monsieur. In the meantime, I will have to remain in an occasional gadfly role. I appreciate your having the thick hide necessary to anyone who places their thought in such a public forum, though!
P.S. Ima Sinnic and Bear Country may be better placed to perform that function; kudos to both, whose criticism of the OP tends to mirror mine.
Actually Ed Kilgore (!) nailed it:
Basically she only “acted” somewhat reasonable, but almost always fell into line with the GOP votes.
Wow, the Democrats might get 60 Senators again! Remember all the great accomplishments Obama racked up the last time?
Thanks for the vote of confidence. I will think about looking into writing it. I, however, know very little about the state except that it is beautiful to visit. I generally do better at short comments.
Sorry, Jon, but I’ve come to the conclusion that good news for the Dem party is generally bad news for progressives.
Yeah — I’m trying to convert some gadflies from their incessant “You should write about X” drumbeat into “I should write about X!” diarists.
I will not speak for some other poster, but for myself, what with HR 347 passing by 388 to 3 yesterday, I am firmly convinced that we live in a totalitarian state. Our candidates and election system only exist so the Big Media people can get some advertising revenue every other year.
The progressives we have in Congress didn’t even vote Aye or Nay yesterday. Even Kucinich was not around to protest the end of our right to protest in the United States.
How do you figure Maine is a Democratic state? The state government is wholly Reapubligan, Governor, House & Senate. The two senators are Reapubligans. So, two house members are Democrats. For how long?
Maine is a red state. They receive a transfer of wealth from their neighbors to run their government. For every dollar they pay in income tax, they receive $1.89.
These chickens are not about to hatch in Maine.
Dreier’s retirement was a foregone conclusion, because his district got carved up six ways by the Citizen Reapportionment Committee. I think there was not a district which contained more than 20% of his old one.
Still, it’s good to see him go. He was always one of those smarmy types who are as partisan as they come, but talks about “my good friends” on the other side of the aisle. He should have been gone ten years ago, but the legislature passed an incumbent-protection plan that locked in a 34-19 Democratic advantage, and I think only one seat flipped in the course of the decade. The new map may result in Democratic pickups of up to 8 seats.
I wonder why this wasn’t front page news. Seems to me to be something important.
Worthy goal.
Probably the 3 Nays don’t want the right to throw shoes to be infringed.