It’s Christmas time, and I’m surrounded by family. Like with almost any large family gathering, the conversation eventually turns to polite questions about work.
The family knows I write about politics, so, over the course of several days, I tend to have a brief conversation about Congress and politics with each member of the family. A common question I have heard several times is, “Is Congress still in session?” And most of this week, the answer was “Yes.” This usually led to a follow-up question that required me to examine part of the reason for the long, late lame duck session: the weird Senate rules allowing delay tactics, cloture voters, and 30 hours of post-cloture ripping time. This was normally greeted with polite disinterest, confusion, or mild scorn for the ridiculousness.
While my family is not a bunch of political activists, they are professionals that pay attention to the news and vote regularly. People like teachers, local government employees, engineers, business managers, and the like.
It was a strong, personal reminder to me that the vast majority of Americans don’t know about or care about the motions to proceed, cloture votes, suspended rules votes, symbolic votes, or the grand tradition of arcane Senate rules. Beyond not paying attention to the ins and outs of the meaningless kabuki show that dominates the minds of people on the Hill, regular Americans often don’t even know whether Congress is in session.
This time with my family just reinforces my firm belief that pursuing good progressive policy meant to help people will become good politics. People don’t care about floor speeches, the silly rules that prevent bills for passing, CBO scores, or show votes for amendments that everyone in Washington knows aren’t going to pass. Most people vote for politicians hoping they will make good decisions that will result in improved lives and communities, not for someone they think will make a great floor speech on C-SPAN 2 before an empty chamber.
My advice to any political party is to focus the bulk of their energy on doing what ever possible, as quickly as possible, to deliver real improvements for the electorate. People pay attention to how the government is affecting their lives, not the show politicians put on for each other.
If Democrats had spent even half as much time on getting more people help with their health care as soon as possible as they did getting that “pretty” CBO score for their bill, I suspect they would have had a better showing last November.



19 Comments
Correctamundo! The performances they have put on the last two years is enough to make a sane person want a padded room. All of it could have been avoided and if we had seen more progress earlier than in the last week of the year all would be different.
Besides, all these last minute wins still have to have funding. I’m worried that they will be swept away in the giant dustpan of teabaggery.
This is my experience as well. People don’t give a rip about procedure, even my lawyer friends and their employees. They don’t care about the day to day crap we watch so closely, and it doesn’t make for interesting conversation. Thank heaven for football and babies.
Hey! It’s-the-art-of-the-possible-process-bipartisanship-don’t-let-the-perfect-be-the-enemy-of-the-good-looking-forward-not-back! You dirty fucking sanctimonious hippies who are purists in need of drug testing!
LOL! Maybe we should speak plainer. Maybe we should tell them in a way they fully understand. Maybe if we said, STFU and get back to work, they would get it.
OT question: I keep getting pop up notices from FDL. I keep my pop up blocker on at all times. IS there somebody trying to send me something and I should turn it on?
Don’t hold your breath. You’re certain to asphyxiate.
That should tell you something! If Lawyers can’t stand to watch it or read it, then it is horribly bad. Just look at all the Legalese they have to read through and deal with daily. That stuff is pretty darn bad!
Yeah. They don’t hear us or see us. If it doesn’t effect them or their family it doesn’t exist.
Never have truer words been spoken.
I’ve been wondering when I see all these shelter stories on the news if they see any of this in Washington. If they were to get a few hundred clips do you think they would take the time to look at it?
Obamanible Wall Street-theatre!
Tens of millions of Americans are doing without, homeless or just in poverty. 1 in 7 are on foodstamps. 10 million out of work another 15 million under employed. Home equity is down 40%. Politicians are in denial.
What will be interesting to see in the new Congress following the planned change in the Senate filibuster rule is if the liberal Senate Democratic caucus has to start using the changed filibuster format to filibuster legislation coming out of the Republican-controlled House especially involving spending or budget cut bills.
Because if I were a Republican in the House, I’d craft legislation agreeable to not only Senate Republicans, but also to Blue Dog Democrats, figuring that if I got enough of these two blocs in the Senate to join in passing House legislation, over 50 votes might be gained, literally placing the liberal Democratic caucus in the minority…at which time any filibuster change might be a help to this Senate Republican/Blue Dog Democrat bloc…depending, of course, on what Sen. Harry Reid did or didn’t do.
IOW, Republican-controlled House tax-cutting program-slashing bills might make it through the “Democratic”-controlled Senate and land on President Obama’s desk for signing. Would he veto a bill that originated in the Republican-controlled House, traveled through the Senate relatively untouched, leaving much of the worst measures intact, finally landing on his desk? I believe we will see this happen over and over again over the next two years. How many will President Obama veto? How many will President Obama sign into law, while presumably holding his nose, like he did in signing the extension of the budget-busting deficit-exploding Bush era tax cuts because he “had to”?
Unfortunately, procedure is supremely important whether people like to face that fact or not. Even kabuki votes on things like cloture have a (malignant) effect, by making it impossible to determine exactly who is blocking progress on end-effect issues, or why.
We’re fighting a losing battle as long as the general public thinks only the concrete end results matter. All the PTB have to do is add another layer of complexity, and for every hydra head of evil we strike down, a dozen new ones will grow in its place. Matt Taibbi explains the process, as it operates in the financial sphere, in Griftopia.
This doesn’t mean, of course, that we have to just accept obfuscatory procedures (like filibusters and secret holds). But even efforts at reform require admitting that the process to be reformed is an important problem.
The situation will remain absolutely hopeless as long as people can’t get excited about abstractions. Our government and our economic system, which control all the concrete end results, are almost purely abstract. I cannot stress this point enough. Do not just accept your family’s attitudes; try to get through to them, no matter how hopeless it looks.
Congress and Obama have already transcended doing anything to improve the lives of the electorate. Nothing could be more obvious. The kabuki is just lies and manipulation designed to obscure the issues and the real effect of the legislation.
Well, that’s why they have all those rules and regulations in the Senate – to prevent this sort of thing. The Majority Leader has complete control over what bills are sent to the floor. If he doesn’t want to have a “Republican” bill up for a vote, it will never get there.
I kinda have to disagree with part of the headline. I think people do “know” about the kabuki. Maybe not in detail but they have a general feeling when they’re being bullshitted and toyed with.
But you’re right about the not caring part. People want results. You can chalk up the Dems big midterm losses to one thing: what the Dems promised wasn’t delivered. You screw the pooch, voters put somebody new in the pooch house.
The problem is that you are giving advice to politicians, and they don’t give a shit about the electorate that is locked into a two-party paradigm and ongoing partisan narratives. You might as well be preaching the virtues of being a vegetarian to lions and tigers.
The Kabuki is not meant to be consciously noticed.
While everyone is too busy with the Holidays the Congressional theater seeps into your subconscious so that all you remember a year from now is that everyone said Obama had a great victory and is on a comeback, the exact opposite of the truth.