Growth in real disposable income leading up to an election is a near-perfect predictor of how the incumbent party will do, says Ezra Klein in a perceptive article. This close correlation should not be surprising. People judge the majority party based on how much their personal economic standing has improved or deteriorated, as well as their friends’ and family’s.
It is always the economy.
With this in mind, we can zero in on the true failure of the Obama Administration and Congressional Democrats from a political standpoint. The data Klein points to show how modest the impact of the actual campaign is on the election. The court intrigue of the Washington bubble, arguments about procedure, CBO price tags and tallies of highly compromised legislative “wins” will have a negligible impact on voters’ decisions.
Yet, despite how unimportant these things are to electoral outcomes, somehow they have become all-consuming priorities for the Administration and Congressional Democrats. Take, for example, the health care bill, which became dominated by one feature — the CBO price tag — at the expense of good policy or politics.
Democrats missed a perfect opportunity to focus on health care reform as a way to inject additional stimulus. Though the Affordable Care Act waits till 2014 to start many of the benefits, it delays implementing taxes or cuts to pay for them until several years beyond that. Without changing the general policy of what is now law, through a combination of Medicaid expansion, temporary COBRA subsidies, better funding of high-risk pools, dental care rebates, voluntary money to states that set up exchanges early and more, the health care bill could have been a way to inject roughly $100 billion of spending into the economy this year, helping people and encouraging start-up businesses. Instead, the new benefits won’t really kick in until 2014.
The most egregious problem for Democrats is they have allowed Senate Republicans to destroy their election hopes in November. Democrats like Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) openly acknowledge that Senate Republicans are using the filibuster to block pro-growth legislation in order to keep the economy weak. As we can see from the data, it is a brilliant political strategy and is likely to pay off for the GOP in November. Yet, with their jobs on the line, Democrats have chosen to defend arcane Senate rules instead of playing procedural hardball to advance good policy and even better politics. The vast majority of Americans don’t even understand the Senate rules that Democrats are defending at the cost of their majority. By not eliminating the filibuster, or at least threatening to as the GOP did to force compromise, Democrats have effectively committed political assisted suicide and taken the economy down with them.
Inside-the-Beltway arguments and deficit self-talk have doomed Democrats in November because they fail to see how important it is to address the immediate needs of regular Americans. Democrats have given up on even trying to improve voters’ economic well being before Election Day.
It brings to mind the probably false legend of Nero fiddling while Rome burned, but even that comparison is unfair. The story claims Nero at least purposely burned the city so he could build a new palace. Democrats are instead arguing about rules, Beltway squabbles and deficits while their own majority goes up in smoke around them.



39 Comments
But But But REPUBLICANS!
Ezra Klein is one of the best in the business of stating the obvious in the most obtuse, unreadable construction possible.
This, is another case in point.
Jon, there is a lot of money to be made in chin stroking and writing Vanilla essays disguised as mature, political analysis. His point is one considered to be common knowledge among a large core of us unwashed masses.
And, of course, its always the fault of the Republicans.
What was the number one issue Americans wanted fix when Obama got elected? Jobs
What is the number one issue Americans want fix now? Jobs
Obama says he went to Harvard, Harvard is not what it use to be, apparently their graduates lack common sense.
Obama intentionally avoided the only issue the american people wanted solved Jobs, to pursue some Republican Agenda.
Americans did not want Obama to pass the Bob Dole health care bill
Obama is a trojan horse, with one mission, to destroy the progressive agenda.
Obama is chasing HOOVER.
Obama is giving Harvard a bad name, Obama seems to lack the ability to see that all of his ideas are failing.
Obama, If FDR was here he would tell you, Progressive IDEAS work.
I think FDR would[Edited by Moderator. No need to go down that path[ him.
This is a feature not a bug. Or rather it is a misunderstanding. The Democrats are doing what they wanted to do. They missed nothing.
Team Obama is doing a brilliant job of this on their own. The Republicans just add a little cover.
Health Care Reform was the stimulus for years to come if single payer was on the table – but Obama was afraid of expanding Federal Spending by 6% of GDP (I know it would only be a pass through to pay claims – but Obama can not sell ice in the tropics) to 28% of GDP, despite the fact it would free up at least 2% immediately (and 8% eventually as a national budget plan for the yearly health cost by the Fed put a stop to run away health care inflation). The 2% of GDP savings would be continuing “stimulus” of more than 200 billion. (it is not really a stimulus because it is not a spending increase – it is a productivity increase that hopefully allows capital to redeployed, new hires, and higher wages, as non-productive CEOs/Senior Management are retired and workers for the insurance companies continue the same jobs as administrative service contract employees to the new Federal Plan – as is now done with Medicare).
When will the folks at the lake come to this very simple and irrefutable conclusion? Have they not seen how the jesters dance in the Kabuki theater that their corporate overlords set up for them daily? These Democrats are only progressive sounding when they are trying to skim out a close election. We have seen what they are when they “govern.”
Don’t you know, Jon?
The mid-terms are going to be all about the verbal gaffes of Joe Barton, Michael Steele, and John Boehner, et al. That’s what Americans REALLY care about, isn’t it?
That’s what President Obama and the DNC are suggesting. It’s the same message on MSNBC’s prime-time line-up.
Jobs and the economy will be a mere afterthought…little more than a footnote.
Kinda has the same flavor as Kramer dropping the N-word or Lindsay Lohan going to jail. We should just start hashing out elections in inTouch magazine, or Cosmo. Or maybe on Access Hollywood or TMZ!
Voters sent Obama and Democrats in large numbers to Washington to govern and to legislate for working people and those that are down and out.
Obama either wouldn’t, couldn’t, or didn’t know how to lead. The rest sat around wringing their hands and let a golden opportunity for Democrats to be in power for years slip through their fingers.
If SS is dismantled they will have successfully destroyed the democrat party.
Said it since day one. Obama wants what Clinton had, Republicans in control of the House and Senate, him in the White House. It would almost guarantee him a second term because you will see how smoothly things get done when this happens. Republicans will write the laws, Obama will sign them, and there will be a big bipartisian love fest because there will be no filibusters or haggling. Obama can then state how smoothly things are going and the public will lap it up. Don’t think for one second Rahm, the mastermind behind this whole deal anyway, wants a Progressive Democratic majority in this deal. They just want a nice, smooth, easy 6 years from November on out, and they will get it. Guaranteed folks.
A WAR ON ENERGY!! NOT A WAR TO STEAL POTENTIAL ENERGY! To bad we still dont get it stupid people! Predicate supply side cost on hit or miss drilled oil wells plus demand and you have supply side horseshit and scumbuggery! Marry brainpower with sun power with ocean water and you have hydrogen? The most ABUNDANT element in the universe?
I guess given all the technological innovations man has effected with drilling refining distributing oil from all over the fucking world those same efforts “utilized” to utilize hydrogen derived from salt water using RFW waves genenrated from harvested solar power would not provide a BENEFIT TO AMERICA!!!!!! STEAM STEAM STEAM AND POTABLE WATER??????
How about a war on energy you DEMORATS AND REUGLICANS!! How about liberating America rather than enslaving US to enenrgy corporations. How about using that same American innovation, wit, and reason we used to defeat the fucking Nazis and liberate the world from scum, to liberate America from energy production methods which pollute kill and untimately undermine life and liberty here and around the world!! How about a real fucking leader!!!
Perhaps Obama is trying to replay the Bill Clinton playbook by having the Republicans controlling Congress. Rahm was blamed for what happened after NAFTA with the Democrats losing Congress, but perhaps that is was the plan all along complete with Clinton getting two termsn
I saw it yesterday on MTP.
This Admin and Congress act like they are insane or stupid beyond belief. However, they are neither.
Which begs the questions……WTF are they doing and why?????????
Exactly!
Just a daily and perpetual dose of kabuki. The players may change, may utter different scripts, assume alternate positions on the world stage, but in the end, it’s all the theater of the absurd and insane.
We need to get rid of the fuckin stage, the players, and the theater. I just do not believe we have the will or the desire, as well as empowerment to get it done and flush all this political BS down the black hole it deserves to go!
It’s mind blowing really. The country came out en masse and voted for this beautiful, intelligent, compelling, well educated and successful young black man. They voted en masse for a Dem Congress. They wanted change so badly. The economy, healthcare, taxation, education, environment…..you name it, and we wanted it changed. Obama and the Dems had a very excited, very hungry country just salivating at their huge electoral wins. Then boom……..it’s been a downward trajectory since.
The GOP are BRILLIANT at setting the tone, and telling the story. They are MASTERS of deception/lies/cheating. The Dems will never be able to win on those items…..the way the Dems/WH could win the story and continue to win the country was by producing what the country needed and wanted. Delivering on the promises made and ideas promoted while campaigning.
I’m not upto snuff on the Senate/Congress rules, regulations, or history. But WTF is the point in a majority if you can’t get done what you want????? There MUST be some way around this filibuster bullshit. There must be someway to let the ConservaDems know that they will never hold a position of power again if they don’t vote for legislation that will help the majority of folks in the country. I KNOW that Obama could have gone out and given a convincing talk about stimulus, HCR, FinReg, etc if he’d really wanted to…..and he didn’t. He could close down Guantano by Exec Order if he wanted to, and he hasn’t. Etc, etc, etc.
This is where he lost me and other Dems, and the Independents. The WH didn’t fight for it’s agenda. If Ben Nelson and others aren’t acting right then why the hell isn’t Obama out there making it known to the whole country???? If the GOP isn’t acting right then why don’t the Dems make them truely filibuster??????
They are either the weakest, most spineless, feckless bunch of losers ever, or they just simply didn’t really want to get the peoples business done.
Lets see a war against Nazis had a tangible effect on the employment situtation in America after a depression. Fossil fuel provided the energy. America’s war effort won the war and Rosie drove rivets, while thousands of Americans died far away! Just maybe a war on energy might provide the same BENEFIT! “JOBS” I quess we Americans are so stupid so uninventive so lazy that we cannot create unless we have a WAR? I guess wars drive most innovations. A WAR ON ENERGY WILL CREATE JOBS! We have one problem. Like the slaveowners who would not change, CORPORTAE ENERGY will not either. We are thier slaves. They will rape this country as they have and continue to do as we exchange percieved liberty for involuntary servitude, where 3/4 of every dollar spent on gasoline is wasted in the form of heat energy a horrible value for the money spent. We just dont get it!
I totally agree
the current batch of corporate politicians calling themselves dems only talk progressive when it is time to get votes.
the force that allows corporate politicians to thrive in the USA is the so call liberal media, that is owned by rich conservative republicans.
Obama is the poster child for the corporate/govt media!
SUN TZU says “all war is base on deception”
Obama is a democrat in name only, Obama is more Reagan than Reagan, and the corporate/govt media protects him from outside critics who know this. Few to any people in the media looks at Obama actions, and say you know Bush would have done the same thing.
The Military and Big Corporations have hijack the USA govt. After the 1960s the Military and Big Corporations made a vow to never let another Walter Cronkite control the USA.
It is a pretty simple plan. If you control the information the american people received you will control the USA. (Fox news proves this every day)
Look at the interest Obama protects, he protects the interest of the Military and Big Corporations.
Look at the Interest Obama does not protect, the interest of the American People.
What sane nation would increase military spending and decrease education spending?
The AMERICAN PEOPLE have been brainwashed beyond belief, the people in congress will never cut military spending, but at the drop of a hat they will cut un-employment benefits, education, social security, etc.
The military and Big corporations are now telling the american people, the wars in Afghan, Iraq, etc. are more important than social security.
What has Obama done for main street? nothing!
it is easy to kill the enemy, that does not know or recognize they are being attack.
the American People have better wake up!
the good news, is none of Hoover ideas will work, and this is causing the Obama white house and congress to collapse.
It is the power of corporation’s undue influence on the political process which has made the people’s business play second fiddle to corporate interest, profit! When slaves where given constitutional protection by the 14th Amendment, the corporate ace card was slipped in, at the state level. This permitted segregation where former slave could not consolidate wealth or political power to even set up a corporation! One hundred years for former slaves and decendants of slaves to have eqaul justice under the law, and still the fight goes on!~
The answer is to Amend the Constitution and place restrictions on corporations political funding as both JEFFFFFFFFFERSON AND MADIIIIIIIIISON DESIRED! They gave US the template and we don’t use it! Legislate it demand it and fuck limp dicked compromised legal decisions like Taney and Roberts! Protect the slaveowners Protect the corporations!!
The fix is in on multiple levels and Orahmba is just a place holder in temporary position for the next game changer from the Repub Insanity Club!
The fix has been in well before the 2008 election, and lots of sound minded and intelligent folks helped ushered in the present dilemma by thinking that we might be getting real change after the clusterfuck of 8 years of King George. Lots of finely honed and desperation driven deception.
When this November rolls around we will be entering the last throes of Elite Empire creation and with the drones, the US version of the SS troops, and the eventual takeover of all media including the Net, we will be soundly defeated and ready for whatever gristmill they want to grind us in.
Outside of a giant upheaval and retaliation of the citizenry, what indicators are there that the total collapse of what was once the US of A’s so called democracy will survive this onslaught???
NONE! If someone has an indicator, tell it!
We will do what we are told, by whoever the elite fascists choose and we will do it gratefully or we will be ground by the grist mill into nothingness or allowed to die in our hovels, poor, without jobs or healthcare, broken emotionally and spiritually.
THAT IS THE FUTURE, unless we wake up and take back our country!…and voting in the current crop of cardboard figures will not do it!…neither will sitting in ever increasing hot water thinking freedom is a comfort we do not have to fight for!
Axelrod on jobs and stimulus: “There’s not a great appetite for it”.
Funny, that seems to exactly coincide with Democratic voters attitudes about voting for the Democratic party this fall.
Amazing how that works.
If Americans would do what they used to do better than anyone else…compete…and work for 70 or 75 cents an hour, India, China, and the Philippines would shut down, jobs would come home, and the recession would be over. They could rent their homes from the banks who took their taxpayer bailout and foreclosed on them, and through Section 8, rent would be affordable and gone would be all the headaches of home ownership. Jeez…it’s so simple. I’m old enough to know the America I knew is gone. Read Gandhi.
I like it! You get it! More of it!!! The corporate elites have fucked America for decades. Now America with considerably diminished resources and as the ashes settle from the last American sodomization, the players that be jockey for the next stab at America’s already bleeding derriere. They have one fucking god, the almighty dollar!
They are parasites to life and liberty!!
So what is the bleeping alternative? The same old fucking shitheads and party line horseshit from a bunch of fucking liars!!!!
How the fuck do you compete when you waste so much money on energy! Lets waste 75 % of the potential energy we buy for our cars. This is a huge sum of money! Lots of Liberty just wasted!! How the fuck can we compete!!! Could you compete at all if you wasted 75 percent of your stored potential energy in the exercise! Get real…….
Americans trade liberty for bullshit everyday!!!
Because the U.S. likely has the most naive and ignorant electorate of any advanced country the best this country can hope for is to bounce back and forth from bad to worst, from worst to bad, like a political ping pong ball.
When the main focus of the Democratic Party is holding on to the huge corporate doners it got during the 2008 campaign, missed opportunities will always be their business.
Clinton got impeached.
The naive and ignorant electorate will get what they deserve for being so asleep at the wheel, but that includes the whole country, because this sickness will eventually touch the ‘untouchables’. The wheel of life does not discriminate.
…and I fear the bouncing back and forth will be more like one tremendous thud as the ball is squashed and all that is left will be the agony and whimper of a crushed citizenry and a country lost!
What was the price of a gallon of gas when you earned your priviledge to drive?
Newt Blute and the rethugs shut down washington?
Sounds like Wal-Mart nation. Read Himmelfarb. Victorian England when the simple folk were so moral and easily satisfied.
Yes, they are the alternative, and at this point, they are going to be running the House and the Senate.
You can spear the messenger, but it’s more effective to try and spear the DC Dems causing the problem.
Good times ahead.
The filibuster is just an excuse.
Liberals can stay home in November and let the Repubs impeach Obama.
Or they can elect Dems to Congress and continue muddling through.
It’s your choice.
What do they think they can impeach him for? Being black?
I thoroughly agree with you about Obama. Obama is not a centrist as he claims but he’s to the right of center. In some respects he appears to be to the right of Nixon. All of us who expected real change and transparency have been duped by this con artist from Chicago. Aside from being able to structure a sentence and not saying nucular I see very little separating him from Bush.